Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dr. Sam Currin's avatar

Excellent column; I share your feelings. How well I remember Helms and Hunt debating the federal cigarette tax in 1984 as if that issue would decide the election. How far we have fallen.

Graham's avatar

I agree with your broader sentiment here (both in terms of the deluge of negative advertising and that very little of modern politics seems to be related to real policy), I do wonder how much of this effect is also down to debates vs online advertising. Even the 2024 Presidential debates had a little discussion of policy, while ads need to be memorable in 15 or 30 seconds, incentivizing ultra-simple messages.

I also find it interesting that you use Jesse Helms (and Jim Hunt to be fair) as a contrast. I wasn't around for Helms, but from I have read from him he is remembered for pioneering nationalized direct-mail fundraising (feeding into the highly expensive ad-happy campaigns of today. EDIT: and 1984 is seen as a particularly extreme case of his tactics foreshadowing the endless negative modern political ad campaign) and for his... controversial campaign messaging (Hands, "He's one of us,"). Do you think that he is viewed sometimes be conservatives with rose tinted glasses, or do you think that liberal criticisms of him are largely baseless?

Ready for more?